My Bumble date held me captive and gouged my eye – in months no one will be watching HIM

Freya McAleer was strangled, beaten and held captive for six hours by her Bumble match. Now his licence ends in March 2027 and she’s terrified he’ll come back.
Smiling woman with brown hair outdoors beside a close-up of her bruised, swollen and bloodshot eye
A recent photo of Freya McAleer. (Picture: Jam Press)
Share

Freya McAleer has a date she can’t stop thinking about.

In March 2027, the man who strangled her, beat her and held her prisoner in her own bedroom finishes his licence, and from then on nobody will be keeping track of where he goes.

James Payne, 33, was jailed in October 2023 after a night of violence that left Freya with a lacerated eyeball, ligament damage and severe bruising.

READ MORE: I was drowning in £12K of debt – then I made bronzer from cocoa powder and cleared it in a YEAR

He left prison in March 2025. The licence period, the final half of his four-year sentence, runs out in four months.

“I’m paralysed with fear by the end of the licence,” the 36-year-old horse trainer and riding coach from Oxfordshire said, as reported by Creatorzine.

Black and white selfie of woman with bob haircut and man smiling, both with red heart stickers on their heads
Freya McAleer and James Payne. (Picture: Jam Press)

“Even more so the closer that date draws near.

“He will no longer be required to check in with his case officer and his whereabouts will no longer be monitored.”

The Bumble match who ticked every box

Freya matched with Payne on Bumble in December 2022, after her marriage ended.

Dating app profile card showing a smiling man in a black top holding an apple, with name and bio text
James Payne’s Bible profile. (Picture: Jam Press)

His profile called him loyal, trustworthy and honest. That was exactly what she wanted.

“We began texting and I felt a spark,” she said.

“After a while, I arranged for him to come over. I was dressed in my loungewear and teddy bear socks with no makeup on, but it didn’t seem to put him off. It felt as if I had known him forever.”

He brought her coffee while she worked and told her constantly how beautiful she was.

When he announced plans for his own landscaping business, she was proud enough to put down a £500 deposit on a van he couldn’t afford, in February 2023.

Close-up of a swollen, bloodshot eye with false eyelashes, 48 hours after an injury
Freya McAleer’s injured eye, 48 hours after incident. (Picture: Jam Press)

The business, she says, barely got going. The drinking did.

“I would come home from work to find him in my house with his feet up, drinking and smoking,” she said.

“At first, I put up with his daily drinking and sloppy attitude because I loved him.”

A threat, then hands around her throat

Side view of a woman's jaw and neck with a yellow-brown bruise below the ear, wearing a blue collared top
Freya McAleer’s bruised jaw a week after incident. (Picture: Jam Press)

The first crack came when she found him assembling a chest of drawers beside a half-drunk bottle of Jack Daniel’s. She got annoyed.

He stormed out, then threatened to post sex videos of the pair if she ever tried to leave.

“His threat terrified me – but it was just the beginning,” she said.

A week later they argued again about his lack of work.

Bare thigh of a person sitting on a toilet with a faint bruise on the side, toilet roll behind
Freya McAleer’s bruised thigh. (Picture: Jam Press)

Freya told him he was taking her for an idiot and threw her wine over him.

She says he put his hands around her throat until she passed out, then smashed her head into the chest of drawers to wake her.

Frightened, she apologised. He begged her not to tell anyone and promised it wouldn’t happen again.

Days later, it did.

Six hours in her own bedroom

Bedroom with a grey upholstered sleigh bed, tufted headboard, and a brown dachshund lying on the duvet
The bedroom where most of the abuse took place. (Picture: Jam Press)

Freya told a friend she planned to get Payne out of the house.

She says he found the messages and started deleting them, along with the evidence she had been quietly collecting.

What followed, by her account, lasted most of a night.

He forced his thumbs into her eye socket and threw her into a radiator as she begged him to think about what he was doing.

Close-up of a split ear with a pale cut running along the outer edge, held apart by a finger
Freya McAleer’s split ear. (Picture: Jam Press)

He hit her around the head as she tried to escape, splitting her ear open.

Then he dragged her by her ponytail into the bathroom and smashed her phone so she couldn’t call for help.

Hours later he moved her to the bedroom, where she says he beat her for six hours.

“I truly thought, unless I could talk him down, I was going to die that night,” she said. “If I had even tried to fight back, I wouldn’t be alive right now.

Bruising and reddish marks on a woman's forearm, with a silver bracelet and a grey bag beside it
Freya McAleer’s arm showing visible bruising from final incident. (Picture: Jam Press)

“All I could think about was my son. I needed to live for him – he couldn’t lose his mum, not like this.”

Eventually he stopped, asked her to forgive him and passed out drunk.

Freya grabbed her puppy, ran from the house and drove to her ex-husband’s, where she urged him to call the police.

Officers took her to hospital and arrested Payne.

Four years, two of them behind bars

Man in a dark puffer jacket with eyes closed, hugging a brown dachshund wearing a red collar
James Payne weeks before hospitalising Freya. (Picture: Jam Press)

On September 11, 2023, Payne was found guilty of four counts of false imprisonment.

He pleaded guilty to assault occasioning actual bodily harm, three counts of non-fatal strangulation and two counts of criminal damage to property valued under £5,000.

On October 27 he received four years, two in custody and two on licence, alongside a 20-year restraining order.

Freya believed he would spend all four years behind bars. She found out shortly afterwards that he wouldn’t.

Smiling woman in sunglasses on her head leaning against the face of a palomino pony in a wooden stable
Freya McAleer with her horse, a few months after James was convicted. (Picture: Jam Press)

As his release approached, the nightmares started, then sleep paralysis, then daily panic attacks.

“Even in the supermarket, I couldn’t breathe,” she said.

“I struggled to be in public out of the fear that he would be waiting for me everywhere I went.”

When he walked out in March 2025, Freya was still living at the last address he knew.

Woman with blonde hair in a grey jumper taking an outdoor selfie with a wooden fence behind her
A recent photo of Freya McAleer at work. (Picture: Jam Press)

She left at once and moved in with her parents. It was meant to be short-term. She still hasn’t found a home.

‘Two years of peace for a lifetime of trauma’

“I think it’s madness how short his sentencing was,” she said.

“Domestic violence is becoming an epidemic – and this is only going to cause more victims to live in fear.

“All of the trauma we’ve been through, court hearings and upheaval, seems like it’s been for nothing.

Swollen elbow with a small cut and red mark on a woman's arm, wearing a cream knitted jumper
Freya McAleer’s swollen and cut elbow from final incident. (Picture: Jam Press)

I don’t even believe I managed a full two years of peace for a lifetime of trauma.”

Beyond the money and the lost home, she lists skin problems, hair loss and PTSD.

Counselling has helped her rebuild, and she says her spark is slowly coming back.

“I do worry that the only thing protecting me is the restraining order, and there’s only so much that can do,” she said.

Large purple and yellow bruise on a person's hip, photographed in a room with purple walls and shelves
Freya McAleer’s bruised hip, second week into recovery. (Picture: Jam Press)

“But I’m determined to be a survivor and show other victims that there is light at the end of the tunnel.”

Why It Matters

Editorial framing. Dating apps have made meeting strangers routine, and most of the safety talk focuses on the first date.

Freya’s story shows where the risk can actually sit: months in, inside the home, and again years later when a sentence quietly winds down and the victim is left doing the maths on her own.

Woman with light brown hair kissing a brown dachshund she is holding close to her chest
A recent photo of Freya McAleer with her dog, Maverick. (Picture: Jam Press)

The UK’s prison overcrowding has kept early release and licence conditions in the headlines, with victims’ groups repeatedly questioning how much warning and protection survivors get as offenders come out.

In March, the case officer stops checking. Freya won’t.

READ MORE: I booked my daughter a 24-hour sleepover so I can play GTA 6 – critics slammed me but she’s been raised SCREEN-FREE

Woman in a brown trench coat outside a university building, beside a police photo of a bag with hidden drugs.

Air stewardess, 26, faced 25 years over £260k heroin haul – then prosecutors dropped EVERYTHING

Prev
Comments
Add a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Updates, No Noise
Updates, No Noise
Updates, No Noise
Stay in the Loop
Updates, No Noise
Moments and insights — shared with care.